If you’ve been searching for thrift stores in Dover, Ohio, you’re in good company. Whether you’re furnishing a vacation rental on a budget, hunting for one-of-a-kind home decor, or simply love the thrill of the find, the greater Tuscarawas County area has a surprisingly rich thrifting scene.
From community-driven nonprofit stores right in Dover to Amish Country gems just a short drive away, here’s a roundup of seven stores worth a browse.
And if you’re planning to make a weekend of it, Your Family’s Place has cozy, well-appointed vacation homes in Dover ready to welcome you.
Thrift Stores in Dover, OH
1. Mission: Thrift Dover
- missionthrift.com
- 715 Commercial Parkway, Dover, OH
If you’re looking for a clean, well-organized thrift store with a clear mission, this Dover staple is a great place to start. Mission: Thrift Dover benefits children in crisis. The store is located at 715 Commercial Parkway and is a member of the Tuscarawas County Chamber of Commerce, which speaks to its roots as a genuine community business.
When you donate, shop, and volunteer at Mission: Thrift, you are investing in the next generation and helping children reach their full potential. You’ll find a rotating inventory of clothing, home goods, and household items, so the selection changes often, and repeat visits are rewarding.
This is the kind of thrift store that gives you a good feeling well after you’ve left the checkout. Open Monday through Saturday from 9 a.m. to 7 p.m.
2. Community Hospice Browse & Buy Resale Store
- 515 Union Ave., Suite 235, Dover, OH
- (330) 365-2026
Also right in Dover, the Browse & Buy Resale Store is one of the area’s most beloved thrift destinations. The store provides a critical source of funds for Ohio’s Hospice patient care while also allowing the community to access reasonably priced, gently used items.
The variety of available items includes housewares, home furnishings, small appliances, carpeting, furniture, linens, clothing, and more. Shoppers on a budget will appreciate that at Christmas, the store provides seasonal items that make decorating very achievable.
Donations are accepted, but the store does have restrictions, so it’s worth a quick call before you drop off. Items that cannot be accepted include mattresses, bed pillows, broken or non-working appliances, and soiled items.
The Dover location is open Monday through Saturday from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. Every purchase directly serves patients and families in the community, making this one of the most meaningful places to browse in the entire area.
Thrift Stores in New Philadelphia, OH
3. Goodwill New Philadelphia
- 260 Bluebell Dr NW, New Philadelphia, OH
- (330) 339-5746
Just a few minutes from Dover in New Philadelphia, the local Goodwill is a reliable go-to for clothing, furniture, home goods, and more. The store accepts gently used clothing, furniture, sporting equipment, books, electronics, and much more at bargain prices.
One longtime shopper noted that clothing mostly ranges from $4 to $7 and the store holds regular half-off sales weekly, making it a genuinely budget-friendly option for the whole family. The store accepts donations on-site, making it an easy, all-in-one stop when you’re decluttering.
The New Philadelphia Goodwill is open Monday through Saturday from 9 a.m. to 8 p.m.
Up early? Make a stop at a local coffee shop along the way!
Thrift Stores in Amish Country Near Dover, OH
The drive from Dover into Ohio’s Amish Country takes 30 minutes or less, opening up a whole new world of thrifting.
These stores carry a unique mix of goods you simply won’t find anywhere else, and most of them support meaningful missions that extend well beyond the store floor.
4. Harvest Thrift Store (Sugarcreek)
- harvestthriftstores.org
- 1915 State Rt 39, Sugarcreek, OH
Located on SR 39 in Sugarcreek, Harvest Thrift Store features new items displayed daily and accepts donations year-round.
This is the kind of store where no two visits look alike. Shoppers can find quality, stylish, and affordable used clothing for men, women, and children, as well as a large variety of dishes, pots, pans, utensils, and small appliances suitable for college students, campers, or everyday home cooking.
Gently used items of all kinds are available to decorate your home, including linens such as curtains, sheets, blankets, and tablecloths.
Unique antiques, furniture, and seasonal items round out the inventory. Harvest Thrift Store is a non-profit 501(c)3 organization, and the proceeds are donated to youth programs both locally and internationally.
The store is open Monday through Saturday from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. and is closed on Sundays.
5. Home & Hope Thrift Store (Apple Creek)
- 9488 Dover Rd., Apple Creek, OH
- (330) 778-0100
This charming store sits right along Dover Road, making it an easy addition to a day trip from Dover. Home & Hope Thrift Store is located just outside beautiful Amish Country and offers a wide variety of clothing, antiques, home decor, books, movies, and more.
The store also features an Amish Nook with used Amish clothes, and carries many kitchen and household appliances, as well as great deals on blankets, throws, pillows, and rugs.
Kids shopping alongside their parents will find plenty to love here, too, with a strong selection of children’s items. Profits go to various charities, so every purchase contributes to something larger than the find itself.
Store hours are Monday through Friday from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. and Saturday from 9 a.m. to 4 p.m.
6. MCC Connections Thrift Shop (Kidron)
- mccconnections.com
- 4080 Kidron Rd., Kidron, OH
A purchase from MCC Connections Thrift Shop improves people’s lives by supporting the work of Mennonite Central Committee and by saving the earth’s resources through recycling and reusing.
The store carries used clothing and accessories and welcomes donations of clean, good-quality, saleable items.
The store’s mission-driven model means that what you donate and what you find on the shelves all feed directly back into global relief efforts and local community initiatives. If you need to contact them before your visit, check the website or call ahead.
MCC Connections is open Monday through Thursday from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m., and on Saturday from 9 a.m. to 4 p.m.
7. Save & Serve Thrift Shop (Millersburg)
- saveandserve.org
- 1108 S. Washington St., Millersburg, OH
Save & Serve Thrift Shop is just about a 45 minute drive from Dover and offers department store shopping at thrift shop prices in Millersburg, Ohio. It’s part of the Mennonite Central Committee Thrift Shop Network, which gives every purchase a global reach.
Shoppers can browse a curated selection of gently used items knowing that every purchase supports a better life for individuals locally and around the world, from funding emergency relief programs to community improvement projects.
The store is stocked across a wide range of categories, and the donation process here is especially convenient. Clothing and small items can be dropped off 24/7 at a drive-thru donation center, while large items and furniture should be brought to Save & Serve during business hours. Pick-up service is also available within a 20-mile radius of Millersburg.
Store hours are Monday through Saturday from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m.
Tips for Thrifting in & Around Dover, Ohio
Getting the most out of thrift stores around Dover comes down to timing, flexibility, and knowing what to expect.
- Visit often—inventory turns over daily, especially furniture and home goods
- Shop Tuesday through Saturday for the best selection and store hours
- Call ahead before donating to confirm accepted items
- Bring measurements if you’re hunting for furniture—good pieces go fast
- Stay open-minded—you never know what you’ll find
- Plan a food stop after—thrifting days tend to turn into full outings, and a pizza at the end just makes it better
Thrift the Perfect Find in and Around Dover, Ohio
From mission-driven storefronts right in Dover to the charming backroads of Amish Country, this area punches well above its weight when it comes to thrifting.
Whether you’re hunting for furniture, home goods, or just love the thrill of not knowing what you’ll find, the stores in and around Dover, Ohio, give you plenty of reasons to browse.
When you’re ready to make a weekend of it, Your Family’s Place has comfortable, beautifully appointed vacation homes in Dover that make the perfect home base for your next thrifting adventure.